Why do good people suffer?
This is a long post with a lot of Christian content. If you don’t want to read about Christian topics, then you should skip this post.
When we suffer, or when we witness suffering, it is natural to wonder “why do good people suffer?” I have certainly heard stories that beg for an answer to this question. Since my diagnosis in early August, I have certainly wondered the same thing at times. Why am I going through all this?
This also has theological implications. I am a Christian, and believe in God. I’ve always tried to be a good person, and I think I’ve succeeded. But I’ve been in pain for more than a year, and have had a very rough 2 months. If God is real, why would He allow this to happen to me?
God never promised His followers that they would not suffer. Indeed, this world is broken, and as His followers live in this world, they should expect to suffer along with everyone else. In Luke 14, Jesus urges his followers to count the cost of following Him:
27 “And whoever does not carry their cross and follow me cannot be my disciple.”
So why would God allow suffering? There are several possible reasons:
Freewill:
God designed us to be free creatures, and make our own decisions. These decisions can cause ourselves or others to suffer. God cannot eliminate suffering without also eliminating our own freewill.
To grow our character:
It is a reality of our nature that we do not grow and mature when things are going great. When things are good, we tend to do the same things we’ve always done. But when we suffer, we try and figure out how to change what’s happening to us. This may lead us to reexamine how we are living and make changes to our attitude or lifestyle. We don’t really grow unless we are suffering.
Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance. Let perseverance finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, not lacking anything. James 1:2-4
… we also glory in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope. And hope does not put us to shame, because God’s love has been poured out into our hearts through the Holy Spirit, who has been given to us. Romans 5:3-5
To allow us to focus on important things:
Suffering allows us to focus on what’s important. Occasionally in Southern California, we have a nearby fire that forces us to get ready to evacuate. When this happens, everyone has to look around and decide what they really want to keep, and what they could live without. For many, the list of keeper items is short, mostly pictures and computers. Everything else can go.
Timing:
We don’t have the full picture, and God knows far more about what is happening now, and what will happen in the future. Very often, we want things to be different, but it’s just not time yet. The right thing at the wrong time is actually the wrong thing. There are things happening that we don’t see. The right timing can make all the difference.
The Mercy of God:
In the Sci Fi movie Minority Report, police can predict the future, and will arrest people for crimes they haven’t committed yet. The question of the film is, is it ethical to prosecute someone for something they haven’t done yet? Observing God’s actions in the Bible, the answer is clearly no. God allows human evil. He will punish evil, but because of His love for us, He waits a long time to do it, sometimes longer than we want. He is waiting for us to turn away from evil, to repent, so that He can have mercy on us.
In the book of Jonah, God sends Jonah the prophet to preach to the Assyrians in Nineveh (now the city of Mosul in Iraq). The Assyrians were the most vicious and cruel conquerors of the time. Jonah justifiably hated the Assyrians. But God loved even the Assyrians and wanted to give them one last chance before destroying them. God withheld the punishment of the Assyrians because He wanted to have mercy on them!
Read the short book of Jonah to find out what happens!
To activate us:
We had a friend and pastor who was one of those “crotchety with a heart gold” types. He was usually grumpy, but he was also usually working hard to help people make their lives better. He had a special gift with the military recruits at Camp Pendleton in particular. When he passed away, we wondered, “what are we going to do without him.” Then it struck me. He had been teaching others to do what he did for years. It was time for all those people he taught to start putting that training into practice. Sometimes suffering helps us get going and do the things we’ve been trained to do.
I don’t know:
Another pastor was diagnosed with a brain tumor. He was in pain for several years before he died. To this day, I have a hard time with his death. I’m sure some of the above reasons apply, but I still have a hard time explaining it. We have to admit, with our limited perspective, that we simply don’t know why some suffering happens.
Does God understand our suffering?
God knows firsthand the injustice of human suffering. We may think that God doesn’t care about our suffering because He’s up in heaven far removed from us. But if Jesus was God in human form, then God experienced all of the suffering that we do. His family was forced to flee as a baby and lived like refugees for years in Egypt, he lost a parent, he went hungry, he was lied about and betrayed by friends. Finally, he was tortured to death using the most painful execution method in history. When we think about the things we have suffered, we have to remember that God knows exactly what that’s like, because He has suffered them too. He knows firsthand the injustice of human suffering.
So why did He go through all that? Hebrews 12:2 says:
2 …Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith, who for the joy set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame, and has sat down at the right hand of the throne of God.
This verse says that Jesus suffered all that “for the joy set before Him.” What is that? What joy was set before Him? Jesus suffered all that so that He could get you! He wanted an opportunity to have you in His Kingdom! Not you as an abstract person, one of 8 billion people on the planet, but you personally. This is why he was satisfied with what He did, all He suffered. Because He gained the opportunity to have you, the opportunity to have you choose Him!
Many of you don’t believe in God, or can’t accept the idea that He exists. I have a challenge for you. If you really want to know, I challenge you to ask Him to show Himself to you.
A warning! God doesn’t do parlor tricks! He won’t do something simply to satisfy your curiosity! But if you sincerely want to know, I guarantee that if you ask Him, He will show Himself to you.
If even one of you is in the Kingdom of God with me because of my suffering, because it caused you to think about life and death, it will be well worth it.
“For momentary, light affliction is producing for us an eternal weight of glory far beyond all comparison.” 2 Corinthians 4:17
Don’t fear, but be smart,
Erik
If you want to subscribe to these posts, click on the “Subscribe” link on the lower right corner of this page.